Directed by
Guru Dutt, Pyaasa is one of the most
cherished films to come out of India in the past century. The movie tells the
story of Vijay, a troubled young poet searching for recognition of his art.
Vijay experiences a taste of fame only to have it stripped away from him by the
scheming of his employer, brothers, and supposed friends. Pyaasa is a social film that reflects the feelings of loss and
disenfranchisement felt by many in postcolonial India. In particular the theme
of hunger is of particular importance to the film; hunger is not only an
important plot point, but inspires critical compositional themes that set the
tone for the entire film. The title, Pyaasa, translates to thirst, and is a
perfect metaphor for the film, that of longing for what you need to live, but
also suffering. The film includes lines like, “In life, besides love and
poetry, there’s hunger,” which further underscores the motif of hunger.
Pyaasa is a film of shadows and
light, and represents a monumental achievement in natural cinematography. Dutt
and Murthy used natural lighting and shadows to create scenes that are full of
depth, and skillfully draw the audience’s attention to certain areas on screen
while carefully veiling others. The use of shadows and light enhance the motif
of hunger, as the exchange of what is seen and unseen creates an imbalance that
leaves the audience yearning for realization. When Vijay first encounters Gulab
he follows her through the columned walkways and alleys of the city as she
lures him to her home (and place of work); there is mystery and allure in this
scene, as our eyes are pulled to the dark places where we can not see but our
hearts encourage us to search. The dark and unknown spaces are fetishized
throughout the film to such an extent that the cinematography even bleeds into
the writing. Vijay’s book of poems for which he achieves great fame is entitled
“Shadows,” harkening to the influence of shadows on the Guru Dutt’s vision for
the film. When Vijay reveals himself to the crowd at his memorial service, his
frame is backlit, so his features are hidden in shadow; this speaks to the fact
that he has lost his identity, and has become disembodied through the betrayal
of personhood by his family and friends. During the ensuing riot brought about
by the revelation of his existence, shadows are used to highlight the intensity
of the scene, as people in the crowd lose their defining features and become
more like monsters or beasts lurking in the shadows, hungry for the opportunity
to lash out in the confusion of chaos behind a veil of anonymity. The final
shot of the film depicts Gulab and Vijay walking hand in hand away from the
camera and into a hazy mist; their identities become blurred, and we recognize
them as allegories for the lost and disenfranchised voices of their generation.
The music
of S.D. Burman plays a very prominent role in Pyaasa, particularly in heightening the melodrama of particular
scenes or creating moments of cognitive dissonance. For example, when Vijay is first spotted by his mother walking
the streets of the city at the beginning of the film, Burman’s score soars to a
dramatic crescendo, with all the strings plying to imbue the scene with a sense
of pathos and longing; it lets us know that this encounter is meaningful, and
painful, particularly for Vijay’s mother, who feels as if her son has abandoned
her. Her only desire is to feed him, to provide sustenance for her favored son,
and in doing so to give her life meaning as a mother. Later, I was struck by
the shrill quality of the speaking voice of the masseuse, Abdul Sattar, particularly
in comparison to his pleasant singing voice. There is a clear disconnect hear,
with Guru Dutt and Burman saying that appearances are not always as they seem. Ambient
sound also plays a subtle role in the film. We often hear the chirping of
crickets in night scenes involving Vijay, which beckons the audience to view
him as in communion with nature. The sounds of nature such as the crickets are
a reflection of the emptiness inside Vijay as he searches for recognition that
he hopes will give his life meaning; he is ravenous for artistic achievement,
but is met only with the sounds of silence. When Vijay is committed to an
insane asylum for claiming to be himself (ironically), there is a great scene
where we see Vijay sitting on the floor surrounded by his fellow inmates. Dutt
masterfully uses sound and silence to create beautiful tension on screen;
despite being the only sane person in the room, Vijay is the only one who is
quiet, refusing to project his frustration.
Eyes are
extremely sensual objects. Over the centuries, stories about eyes have emerged
insinuating that eyes can bewitch men, turn people to stone, or even kill. In Pyaasa, Guru Dutt uses the close up,
particularly drawing attention to actor’s eyes, to create scenes of tension and
expressiveness. “To get
proper expressions from the artist, to convey to the audience the intensity of
those expressions. Shooting mainly in mid or long shots would not have given
those expressions in that way. For him, everything had to be in close shot.
(Murthy, 1999) Dutt utilizes close ups through a large portion of the
scene where Gulab and Vijay first meeting, focusing particularly on Gulab’s
eyes, which are sharp and alluring. Gulab’s hypnotic gaze entices Vijay to
follow her to her home, where she hopes to make him a customer; her eyes are
not glamorous, but that of a cunning albeit playful predator. She enamors
Vijay, and we can see the hunger in his features as he stumbles seemingly
without choice after her; his curiosity creates a burning desire inside him to
learn how she knows of his poetry. Later, when Vijay and Meena encounter each
other in the elevator, Dutt and Murthy use a close up to create the impression
that they are the only two people in the elevator. They drink up each other’s
faces, and become lost in the carnal orgy of reverie over their past romantic
relations.
Pyaasa broke a number of conventional cinema norms upon its release; the use of camera movement in musical shots, a female heroine who is also a prostitute, an unhappy editing. The film is a powerful melodrama that utilizes unique compositional elements designed to propel the emotional tension of the story. In Pyaasa, hunger becomes a motif that speaks to the disenfranchisement of the common man, and the desire for self actualization that – for most – never materializes in the face of overwhelming societal pressure to perform and be productive.
I found your blog post to be very interesting in its detailing of the symbolism of Pyaasa. Symbolism plays an important role in film in general, but is often ignored by the audience. I particularly liked your analysis of the symbolism of shadows. This is particularly effective as Pyaasa is a black-and-white film.
ReplyDeleteYou also explored Pyaasa's soundtrack and composition. Sound usually coordinates with the action of a movie, so it had hardly occurred to me that it could also be used to generate dissonance - different speaking and singing voices, silence in the midst of noise. Your interpretations of the movement and framing used in the film - the close-up of Meena's face shown behind the bars of the elevator like the face of a caged beast, the movement of the camera while Gulab runs from the constable reminiscent of the point of view of a hawk swooping down on its prey - were also intriguing.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhile I will comment in a more detailed manner later, I just have to write that I really love this post! Your attention to cinematography is so great! We'll done
ReplyDeleteWhile I will comment in a more detailed manner later, I just have to write that I really love this post! Your attention to cinematography is so great! We'll done
ReplyDeleteTo Patrick, I very much enjoyed your theme of hunger that you found in the movie and your attention to the title being Thirst made me realize even more how important hunger really was for the film. The importance behind names always seems to escape me in my reviews as my brain defaults to accepting any other languages at face-value when it seems that both Bollywood films have made deliberate use of heavy-handed symbolism in the choice of names for characters. So, noticing the title being Thirst and recognizing the many scenes that incorporate an element of hunger/thirst to me was quite intriguing to hear.
ReplyDeleteI thought the details you mentioned about the cinematography was fantastic. I am so used to thinking about more modern cinema, so I hadn't considered the natural lighting in the film. I appreciate that you mentioned the specific scene where Gulab is singing to Vijay for the first time, because I noticed myself leaning up to the screen during that scene because I wanted to see. I like how many symbols our classmates are pointing out, this film has many different symbols and interpretations. But I especially enjoyed the idea of hunger and the disenfranchisement of man.
ReplyDeleteI thought the details you mentioned about the cinematography was fantastic. I am so used to thinking about more modern cinema, so I hadn't considered the natural lighting in the film. I appreciate that you mentioned the specific scene where Gulab is singing to Vijay for the first time, because I noticed myself leaning up to the screen during that scene because I wanted to see. I like how many symbols our classmates are pointing out, this film has many different symbols and interpretations. But I especially enjoyed the idea of hunger and the disenfranchisement of man.
ReplyDeleteVery well-written post, Patrick! I especially liked your attention to cinematic elements, such as the use of sound as well as the use of light and shadows. The latter is especially important in black and white films as it adds depth to characters and creates a certain moods. I think that your post is really about the symbolic use of shadows more than it is about hunger although the latter too is a very important trope in the film (it is actually even more important in the next film we're watching, Mother India). In its focus on a tragic character, Pyaasa follows the very popular film Devdas, which was based on S.C. Chattopadhyay's novel of the same name. However, Pyaasa combines powerful social critique along with a focus on a disenfranchised protagonist.
ReplyDelete